Pavers, walls, fire pits and sod in Allen, Dallas, Plano and McKinney(469) 283-6279
Call (469) 283-6279

Guide

Wood Burning or Gas Fire Pit for an Allen Backyard?

Last updated November 10, 2026

You've decided on a fire pit, and now the whole thing hangs on one choice. Wood gives you the crackle and the smell you grew up with. Gas lights with a switch and doesn't send smoke into anybody's bedroom. One homeowner put the worry bluntly: "If you're asking this question it means you probably won't use it very often." It's a fair point, and it's the place to start, because how often you'll use it matters more here than the type of flame.

Both are good choices for an Allen backyard. Which one is right comes down to how you'll use it, how close the neighbors are, and how much tending you want to do on a weeknight.

The short answer for an Allen backyard

Wood burning or propane gas fire pit?

Wood is warmer and has the crackle, but it smokes, it takes tending, and a county burn ban can stop it. Gas lights with a switch, barely smokes and turns off when you go inside, though it doesn't throw the same heat. If you want something you'll use on a random Tuesday, or the house next door sits close, gas usually wins.

What a wood fire gives you, and what it asks for

People who love wood love it for good reasons. "Nothing beats a wood fire pit. The crackle, the ambience, moving the coals and adding more wood," one homeowner wrote, and plenty of people agree. A wood fire is also the warmer of the two by a wide margin, which matters on the handful of cold nights North Texas gets each winter.

The cost is the work around it. You need dry wood stored somewhere, a fire that takes a while to get going, and an hour at the end of the night waiting for it to burn down before you can go to bed. One homeowner who had a wood fireplace said they "only used maybe 2-3 times per year because I was never going to sit down long enough to justify starting and tending the fire." That's the regret behind a lot of wood pits. The pit works fine, and it still ends up as a Saturday-only thing.

Smoke is the other half. On Allen lots, with houses close together and a cedar fence between you, the smoke goes wherever the wind sends it. One parent described it from the other side of the fence: "Our baby's room is on the back of our house so any time they burn, smoke comes into the baby's room." Dry, seasoned wood smokes much less than green wood, but no wood fire is smoke-free.

Where gas makes life easier

Gas is the low-effort option, and people who switch tend to say so. "Propane is much easier. Refills anywhere, quick on and off, no cleanup, no meaningful smoke to deal with," is how one homeowner summed it up. There's no ash to shovel out and no embers floating toward the fence, and when you're done "you just turn off the gas and go."

That ease changes how often a pit gets used. Another homeowner's advice was simple: "If it's gas you'll turn it on a surprising amount." A gas pit gets lit for twenty minutes with a coffee or a glass of wine, which almost never happens with wood.

The downside is heat. A gas flame looks good but it doesn't warm you the way a wood fire does, and one person who tried to get more out of theirs was told "There is nothing you can do to gain more heat for gas fire pits." If you picture sitting around it in a heavy jacket on a January night, wood will feel better. If you picture a cool October evening on the patio, gas is plenty.

Gas also comes up when a burn ban is on. A county burn ban can stop wood fires even when your pit is legal, and those bans tend to arrive in the dry stretches when sitting outside is most tempting. Whether gas is allowed during a ban depends on the order, so check yours before you count on it. The fire pits and fireplaces page lays out the other choices that come with either fuel, from the liner to the base.

Propane tank or a natural gas line

If you go gas, the next question is where the gas comes from. A propane tank hides in the pit or a side table and needs swapping when it runs dry. A natural gas line is trenched from the house to the pit, and then you never think about fuel again.

People who've done the line tend to say it's worth it if the pit gets real use. "The buried line is worth it if you'll use the pit a lot, mostly for never hauling tanks again," one homeowner wrote in a landscaping forum. Another put the opposite side well: "If a tank of gas will last long enough that you'd only need 1-2 tanks per year, then I'd probably stick with propane."

A natural gas line is a plumbing job with a trench across the yard, so plan it before the patio goes down, not after. In Allen, call Building and Permitting at 214.509.4130 and ask whether the line needs a permit. If you live in Plano, Dallas or another nearby city, check with your own city before the trench is dug.

Picking the one you'll still use in three years

Start with how you'll use it. If it's mostly for a few big nights a year with friends, a wood pit will make those nights great and won't bother you sitting quiet the rest of the time. If you want something you'll light on a weeknight because it's nice out, gas is the one that gets used.

Some households end up with both: "gas for ambiance, Bonfire for heat/larger groups." That's a bigger build, but it's worth knowing that a portable wood pit for the occasional big night and a built-in gas pit by the patio is a common way people settle it.

Think about the neighbors too. If the back of the house next door is close to where the pit would go, gas saves you the conversation about smoke.

What a good crew sets up either way

Wood or gas, the pit needs the same groundwork. A good pro measures where it can legally sit first, because the distance from the house, the fence and any pergola depends on your city and often on the fuel. Our rundown on how far a fire pit has to be from the house covers the Allen and nearby city rules.

They'll line a wood pit with fire brick or a steel insert so the ring doesn't crack, build the pit and the pad on compacted crushed stone so the clay under Allen yards doesn't tilt it, and leave drainage in the bottom so rain doesn't sit in the bowl. A gas pit gets the same base plus a burner sized for the bowl and a cover. If you'd rather build a wood pit yourself, our guide on how to build a backyard paver fire pit walks through it.

If you'd like someone to look at the yard and help you choose, the fire pits and fireplaces page shows what the work involves. Call (469) 283-6279 and we'll connect you with a paver and hardscape pro serving Allen, or send a note through contact us.

Call (469) 283-6279